Rules Comparison 1998-99 Hockey Season

This chart has been created to assist you with the differences between the National Federation, NCAA and USA Hockey rules book.

Thanks to Bob Hayden, USA Hockey, Inc., National Referee-in-Chief for his hard work in creating this chart.

Rule (Situation)

Dif

N F H S

NCAA

USA Hockey

 

SECTION 1 - RINK

       
Goalkeeper warm-up area defined

U

No rule No rule Expanded Privileged Area
Maximum non-players on bench

x

Five (5) Six (6) [B.Minor after warn] Four (4)
No Tobacco/Alcohol on ice or bench

x

Prohibits Tobacco (minor) Ejection from game Bench minor

 

SECTION 2 - COMPOSITION OF TEAMS

       
Maximum players in uniform

x

Maximum 20, including goalkeepers Maximum 18 players; 2 or 3 goalkeepers Maximum 20 total, maximum 18 players (Youth)
Visiting team must wear dark uniforms

U

Required Required No rule
Logo limitations on uniform

U

Yes (logos and flags) Yes (logo restrictions only) None
Captain coming off bench to complain

x

First - Misconduct;
Second - Game Misconduct;
Third - Game Disqualification
All - Misconduct All- Minor
Captains and Referees meet before game

U

Required Required No rule
More than 19 Players + 3 Goalkeepers on the ice in the pre-game

N

No rule - implied only rostered players may be on the ice Bench minor penalty No rule - implied only rostered players may be on the ice
Roster correction after game begins

N

OK if inadvertent; minor penalty Not permitted; bench minor penalty assessed OK if inadvertent; bench minor penalty assessed
Substituted goalkeeper eligible to return

U

Next stoppage Next stoppage Resumption of play
Jersey number in addition to back

x

Both sleeves Front or both sleeves No rule
Warm-up for substitute goalkeeper
(first entry into game)

F

1 minute, if requested None None
Warm-up for regular goalkeeper when returning after injury

F

1 minute, if requested None None
Spare goalkeeper required on bench

N

No rule Yes, at start of game, or bench minor No rule; recommended in playdowns
"Temporary" goalkeeper

U

No rule No rule Permitted
Not starting with announced lineup

N

Permitted Bench minor penalty Permitted (except Juniors)
Pucks on ice before start of second or third periods

N

No rule Charged with time-out; bench minor if time-out already used No rule
Last 2 minutes or OT - Substitute goalkeeper requirements

F

Must remain on ice until next stoppage or delayed penalty No restrictions No restrictions
Receiving pass from defending zone upon returning to the ice after penalty expiration

N

Not permitted unless tagging Permitted Not permitted unless tagging
Goalkeeper "off the ice" on a change

N

Within 10 feet of bench At bench, out of play Within 10 feet of bench
Recovery time for injured goalkeeper

x

2 minutes "Reasonable time" None
Unconscious player rule (requires written physician OK to resume play)

F

Required No rule No rule
Stoppage for non-penalized player

F

Immediate (regardless of possession) Immediate when his team has possession Immediate when his team has possession

 

SECTION 3 - EQUIPMENT

       
Skates not conforming to rules

F

(1) Warn; (2) Game Misc. Not permitted to play Not permitted to play
Throat protector - Goalkeeper
Throat protector - Player

F
F

Required
Recommended
Recommended
Not required
Recommended
Not required
Player’s helmet comes off during play

F

Immediate stoppage Must replace (out of play) or go to bench Must replace (out of play) or go to bench
HECC-approved helmet

N

Required Recommended Required
Wearing helmet on players’ and penalty bench

N

Required. Violation - Misc. Not required Required. Violation - Misc.
Mouthguard not worn - Goalkeeper

x

Minor Not required equipment Misconduct
Mouthguard not worn - Player

F

(1) Misc; (2) Game Misc. (1) Misconduct after warning Misconduct (all)
Mouthguard - non-clear color

N

Required Recommended Required
Mouthguard - attached to facemask

N

Required No rule Required
Cut palm on glove

U

Misconduct Misconduct Minor
Warning prior to equipment violation

x

No: (1) Misc.; (2) Game Misc. Yes Implied, not required
Casts / splints

N

OK if adequately covered and physician-approved No rule OK if adequately covered and physician-approved
Wearing jewelry (except religious/medical)

F

(1) Misc.; (2) Game Misc. No rule No rule
Equipment request limitation

x

Sticks, Goalkeeper Equipment Sticks, Skates, Goalkeeper Equipment Anything in Section 3 which has specifications
Location of logos on puck

N

No rule Limited position No rule
 

SECTION 4 - PENALTIES

       
Bench minor penalty defined

F

No rule Yes Yes
Coincident minor penalty rule

N

Equal number of minors offset Equal number of minors offset unless teams at full strength Equal number of minors offset
Minor penalty termination when scored upon

F

First minor being served Minor causing short-handed at time of goal Minor causing short-handed at time of goal
Player/GK ejected after second Major

U

No No Yes (plus 2 game suspension)
Game suspension for Game Misconduct

U

No No Yes (if not 3rd man in)
5-penalty maximum/game (player/GK);
15-penalty maximum/game (coach)

U
U

No
No
No
No
Yes (Game Misc.)
Yes (Next game suspension)
Progressive suspension

U

Yes (Disqual. Penalty) Yes (Disqual. Penalty) No
Match penalty provision

U

No No Yes
Maximum Disqualifications per player per game

F

One No limit No limit
Goalkeeper must remain in Privileged Area throughout Penalty Shot attempt

N

Not required Yes Not required
Who takes Penalty Shot if player selected is injured or ejected, or Captain has choice

U

Any teammate not then serving a penalty Any teammate not then serving a penalty Teammate on the ice at the time of infraction
Goalkeeper must serve his own major and/or misconduct penalties

U

Yes Yes No
 

SECTION 5 - OFFICIALS

       
Approved Officiating systems

x

RR or RRL or RLL RR or RRL or R-2AR RR or RLL (not RRL)
2-man system if 3-man and 1 incapacitated

F

2 Referees 2 Referees or Ref.-Line. 2 Referees or Ref.-Line.
Linesman report observed MINOR pen. to Ref.

U

No No "Injury Potential" minors only
1-Referee: Face-offs

N

Start of periods, after goals Start of game only Start of periods, after goals
 

SECTION 6 - PLAYING RULES

       
Awarded goal for certain Penalty Shot situations if goalkeeper is not on the ice:
- Fall on or pick up puck in crease
- Thrown stick (Defending Zone)
- Fouled from behind (breakaway)

U

Never awarded goal Never awarded goal Awarded goal (all 4 situations)
Verbally abusing Official after game -- player

U

Disqualification Disqualification Misconduct or Game Miscond.
Foul language on players’ bench -- player

U

Misconduct Misconduct Misconduct or Bench Minor
Continuing altercation

U

Disqualification Disqualification Misconduct or Game Miscond.
Touching/Holding Game Official -- player

U

Disqualification Disqualification Misconduct or Game Miscond.
Banging boards with stick -- player

U

Minor Minor Misconduct or Game Miscond.
Obscene Gesture -- player

U

Misconduct or Game Miscond. Misconduct or Game Miscond. Game Misconduct
Racial or ethnic slur

U

Misconduct or Game Miscond. Misconduct or Game Miscond. Game Misconduct
"Detrimental Conduct" -- player or Team Official

U

No rule No rule Gross Misconduct
Physically harming Game Official or opposing Team Official -- player

U

Disqualification Disqualification Gross Misconduct
Verbal abuse to Game Official after game by Team Official

x

Disqualification Supplementary Discipline (1) Bench Minor, (2) Game Misc.; Gross Misc. if threat
Obscene Gesture by Team Official

x

Minor or Game Misconduct Bench Minor Game Misconduct
Physically harming Game Official by Team Off.

x

Disqualification Supplementary Discipline Gross Misconduct
Checking from behind

N

Minor plus Misconduct or Disqual.; DQ required if thrown into boards or goal. Minor or Major; Major and Game Misconduct if thrown into boards or goal Minor + Misconduct, Major + Game Misconduct, or Match; 5+GM if into boards or goal
Face-off for interference from bench

N

Last play Offending team end zone spot Last play
GK freezes puck on ice when he is out of crease, puck in front of goal line (in Priv.Area)

N

No penalty Minor (interpretation) No penalty
Instigating Fisticuffs

U

No special rule No special rule Minor
Fisticuffs, including player struck during altercation who continues by retaliating

U

Disqualification Disqualification Minor, Double Minor, or Major + Game Misconduct
Subsequent player enters altercation

x

Disqualification No automatic penalty First in - Game Misconduct;
Others - no automatic penalty
Intentionally dropping stick or gloves(altercation)

F

Misconduct Minor Minor
Closing hand on puck (not in crease)

N

Stoppage only Minor (if thrown) Stoppage only
High Stick definition

U

Above 4 feet Above 4 feet Above normal shoulder height of checking player
Goalkeeper play puck with high stick

N

No Permitted No
High sticked puck; face-off location other than end spot in Defending Zone

N

End spot (Defending Zone) for all situations Last play or zone line if done by attacking team (at equal strength or short-handed) End spot (Defending Zone) for all situations
Grabbing Facemask

N

Disqualification Major Major + Game Misconduct
Kick shot (skate kicks stick blade)

U

Misconduct Misconduct No rule
Icing, through crease, goalkeeper off the ice

U

No icing No icing Icing
Player leaves players’ bench or penalty bench during altercation

F

Major Disqualification Major + Game Misconduct
Leaving penalty bench during time-out

F

Permitted Not permitted Not permitted
Extra player prevents breakaway

x

Penalty Shot + Misconduct Bench Minor, Misconduct, and Penalty Shot Penalty Shot
Player pushed off-side

U

No off-side No off-side Off-side
Tag-up to nullify delayed off-side

U

Yes Yes No (Yes at Junior & Sr. male)
Imaginary lines at top of face-off circles as determinant for intentional off-side

F

Yes No No
Off-side error

N

Neutral Zone spot Center spot Neutral Zone spot
Carrying puck behind net more than once per period (not being checked)

N

No rule Minor No rule
Additional puck on ice

N

Stop only if interferes with play Stop at change of possession Stop only if interferes with play
Team refuses to start play when ordered to do so by Referee

U

(1) Warn, (2) 3-min. to comply, (3) Major if comply or forfeit if no comply (1) Warn, (2) 3-min. to comply, (3) Major if comply or forfeit if no comply (1) 15 seconds, (2) Bench minor, (3) 15 seconds, (4) Suspend
Thrown stick

U

Preventing a goal: Pen.Shot
Otherwise: minor
Preventing a goal: Pen.Shot
Otherwise: minor
At puck in Def.Zone: Pen.Shot, Otherwise: minor
"Mercy Rule" (ending game early)

F

Permitted No No
Time of period

x

15 minutes 20 minutes 20 minutes maximum
Max. period length, sudden-death overtime

x

8 min. (no resurface) 5 min. (no resurface) 10 min. (no resurface)
Video review

N

No rule Tournament competition only No rule
Location of "fouled from behind" to receive a Penalty Shot

U

Attacking Zone Attacking Zone Attacking side of center line
Unnecessary Roughness

x

Minor or Major Minor Minor or Double Minor, except for hit above shoulders
Avoidable check to player in possession

N

Minor or Major No rule Minor or Major
 

SIGNALS and PROCEDURES

       
Goal scored - blowing the whistle

N

Yes No Yes
Icing signal, non-whistle arm, back official

N

Vertical 66° above horizontal Vertical
Delayed off-side

U

Non-whistle arm vertical; whistle arm angled toward line Non-whistle arm vertical; whistle arm angled toward line Non-whistle arm vertical; whistle arm normal